Miller Urey Experiment: Definition, Purpose, Results & Facts

What Is The Miller-Urey Experiment?

The Miller-Urey experiment was one of the key studies that Stanley Miller and Harold Urey conducted in 1953. It simulated the early Earth environment to test abiogenesis associated with the spontaneous eruption of simple life forms from non-living matter.

The importance of this experiment lies in the fact that it offers a basis whereby simple organic compounds, could be built up from inorganic precursors under conditions that might have existed on primordial Earth.

Previous to the Miller-Urey experiment, several leading theories on life origins were mostly speculative. The works by Alexander Oparin and J.B.S. Haldane speculated that early Earth atmospheres could have been such that the spontaneous generation of organic compounds from simple molecules could occur. This was not tested until Miller and Urey came up with their so-called experiment.

Latest: NEET 2024 Paper Analysis and Answer Key 

Don't Miss: Most scoring concepts for NEET | NEET papers with solutions

New: NEET Syllabus 2025 for Physics, Chemistry, Biology

NEET Important PYQ & Solutions: Physics | Chemistry | Biology | NEET PYQ's (2015-24)

The scientific environment of the early 1950s was ripe for a question about life's origin. Advances in chemistry and biological research set the stage for Miller and Urey to test the abiogenesis theory by simulating a controlled laboratory experiment.

Setup Of The Experiment

The main purpose of the Miller-Urey experiment was to find the conditions of primitive Earth. This later proved to be an experiment conducted to explain whether such conditions gave rise to organic compounds necessary for life.

Apparatus And Materials

Glass Tubes and Flasks: These were used to contain the experimental mixture and provide the medium through which gases could circulate.

Electrodes: These supplied electrical sparks that simulated lightning.

Procedure

Gas Mixture Introduction:

A gas mixture of Methane gas, CH₄, with Ammonia NH₃, Hydrogen, H₂, and Water Vapour, H₂O was introduced into a closed system of glass tubes and flasks.

Electrical Simulation:

Electrical sparks were created with electrodes, mimicking lightning storms that are believed to have been common on primitive Earth.

Cooling And Condensation:

The mixture is allowed to cool, and the gases condensed back into the liquid water trap.

Collection And Analysis:

After a week, the liquid collected was analysed, and the presence of organic compounds was detected.

Result Of The Experiment

The experiment produced a wide array of organic compounds including amino acids, which are, of course, the very building blocks of proteins and thus some of the prime constituents of living cells. This was an important discovery in terms of actually providing empirical evidence that life from simple inorganic molecules could have evolved under the right conditions.

Table: Organic Compound Detected

Criticism Of The Miller-Urey Experiment

One of the major criticisms against the Miller-Urey experiment lies in the composition of the atmosphere that was used. Miller and Urey held that the primitive atmosphere was very strongly reducing, rich in CH₄, NH₃, H₂, and H₂O. However, subsequent experiments suggested that early Earth's atmosphere might have been much less reducing and probably made of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, and water vapour, with a trace of hydrogen. This might then affect radically the kinds of organic molecules produced as a result of the different atmospheric compositions.

Electrical sparks imitated lightning as the energy source in the experiment, which would correspond to one plausible energy source for prebiotic chemistry. Other possible sources of energy include ultraviolet radiation, volcanic activity, and hydrothermal vents. Such alternative energy sources have been tested in other experiments, with equivocal results, suggesting that pathways for the origin of life can be much more diverse than that indicated by this classic experiment.

Given its pristine, controlled conditions, this experiment in the laboratory does not account for the impurities, catalytic surfaces, and variety of minerals found on early Earth. Under realistic conditions, several variables would have existed that could have affected the actual synthesis and stability of the organic molecules.

Alexander Oparin and J.B.S. Haldane postulated that life on early Earth began through a gradual chemical evolution of carbon-based molecules in a "primordial soup." While growing organic molecules in the lab under prebiotic conditions, the Miller-Urey experiment provided evidence for this hypothesis; however, it essentially only tested a very small part of what Oparin and Haldane had in mind. Their theories generally envisioned a longer time frame and a much broader set of chemical processes.

Conclusion

The Miller-Urey experiment was the first of its kind to demonstrate that, from inorganic precursors, organic molecules can spontaneously form under conditions similar to early Earth. An important milestone had been reached within these scientific investigations into abiogenesis and the origin of life.

Further research, inspired by the Miller-Urey experiment on the origin of life, has been oriented towards different environmental conditions, alternative energy sources and more complex sets of organic molecules which can be synthesised. Many questions remain, but Scientific inquiry is tasked with uncovering life's beginnings.

Recommended video for "Miller Urey Experiment"