Reversible, Irreversible, Polytropic Process

Reversible, Irreversible, Polytropic Process

Edited By Shivani Poonia | Updated on Jul 02, 2025 06:31 PM IST

A reversible process in thermodynamics is a hypothetical process in which a system undergoes a change of state to a given final state such that the process can be reversed and that change of state made nil—a net change nil, in both the system and its surroundings. Reversible processes occur at an infinitely slow pace since a system is considered to be in a condition of complete equilibrium at all instances of time during the process. They are primarily used for theoretical purposes and produce maximum efficiency among the limiting values for actual processes.

This Story also Contains
  1. Reversible or Quasi-Static Process
  2. Irreversible Process
  3. Polytropic Process
  4. Some Solved Examples
  5. ∴Q=−w=Summary
Reversible, Irreversible, Polytropic Process
Reversible, Irreversible, Polytropic Process

Reversible or Quasi-Static Process

It is carried out in such a way that the system remains in a state of equilibrium. All changes occurring at any part of the process will be exactly reversed when the change in carried out in the opposite direction.

  • It involves slow changes during operation.

  • This process may occur in any direction.

  • Here driving force and opposing force differ with each other by a very small value.

Irreversible Process

Here the direction of change can not be reversed by small changes in variables. All processes occurring naturally are reversible

  • It involves fast changes during operation.

  • It is a unidirectional process.

  • Here, driving and opposing forces differ by a large amount.

Polytropic Process

PVm = constant is known as a general or polytropic process

If m= 0, the process is constant pressure.

If m = 1, the process is isothermal.

If m = γ , the process is adiabatic.

Recommended topic video on (Reversible, Irreversible, Polytropic Process)


Some Solved Examples

Example 1: Mixing alcohol with the water is :

1)Reversible Process

2) Irreversible Process

3)Quasi-static Process

4)None of the above

Solution

An irreversible process is a process in which after the process has been completed in the forward and reverse orders, the system fails to return to the initial state. As water and alcohol can’t separate themselves, hence it is an irreversible process.
Hence, the answer is the option (2).

Example 2: In an irreversible process in which only Pressure-Volume is taking place at constant T and P the change in Gibbs free energy (dG) and change in entropy (dS) are related as :

1) dS is negative and dG positive (dS))V,E>0,(dG)T,P>0
2) dS is positive and dG is negative (dS))V,E>0,(dG)T,P<0

3) dS is negative and dG is negative (dS))V,E<0,(dG)T,P<0

4) Both are positive (dS))V,E=0,(dG)T,P=0

Solution

An irreversible process is a spontaneous process, so for spontaneity change in entropy (dS) must be positive and the change in Gibbs free energy (dG) should be negative.
Hence, the answer is the option (2).

Example 3: The irreversible process is due to

1)Lack of equilibrium

2)Involvement of dissipative forces

3) Both (1) and (2)

4)None of the above

Solution

Irreversible Process - The process is carried out in such a manner that the system is in thermodynamic equilibrium only at the initial & final stage of the process but not at the intermediate stage. In the case of any Irreversible Process at the intermediate stages of the process, the different state functions such as pressure, temperature, etc. are not defined. Both (1) and (2) are major reasons for irreversibility.

Hence, the answer is the option (3).

Example 4: Any series of operations so carried out that at the end, the system is back to its initial state is called

1)Boyle's Process

2)Adiabatic cycle

3) Cyclic process

4)Reversible process

Solution

In a cyclic process, a series of operations are carried out such that at the end of the series of processes, the system is back to its initial state.

Hence, the answer is the option (3).

Q=w=Summary

Reversible processes are idealized ones in which changes are so gradual that the system is in all instances in thermodynamic equilibrium. During such a process, there are no dissipative effects, such as friction or unrestrained expansion. Reversibility implies that the system and the surroundings may be taken back to their original states without a net change. This concept may be used to define upper-efficiency limits for engines and other thermodynamic systems, even though reversibility is unattainable in practice. The main characteristics are that it involves infinitesimal changes, no production of entropy, and maximum workout. Examples include quasi-static processes and isothermal expansions/compressions in ideal gases. Reversible processes serve as benchmarks for assessing the performance of real, irreversible processes.


Irreversible processes are natural processes exemplified by spontaneous changes, friction, turbulence, unrestrained expansion, etc., which lead to entropy production. Work output from such processes is smaller than from their reversible counterparts since it is impossible to return the system and surroundings to their original states spontaneously, that is, without external intervention. Irreversibility is inherent in all real processes. Common examples include natural heat transfer, free expansion of gases, and real engine cycles. Irreversible processes point out the practical limitation in energy conversion and efficiency. Understanding them plays a crucial role in the design of systems that would help minimize losses of energy while maximizing performance, recognizing that some amount of irreversibility is always present in any real application.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How does an irreversible process differ from a reversible one?
An irreversible process is a thermodynamic process that cannot be reversed without leaving a net change in the system or surroundings. Unlike reversible processes, irreversible processes occur in finite time, involve energy dissipation (e.g., friction), and result in an increase in entropy. All real-world processes are irreversible to some degree, making them more practical but less efficient than their reversible counterparts.
2. How does entropy change in reversible vs. irreversible processes?
In a reversible process, the entropy change of the universe (system + surroundings) is zero. The entropy increase in one part is exactly balanced by an entropy decrease in another. In contrast, irreversible processes always lead to a net increase in the entropy of the universe. This fundamental difference highlights why reversible processes are ideal but unattainable, while irreversible processes represent real-world phenomena.
3. How does the efficiency of a heat engine relate to reversible and irreversible processes?
The efficiency of a heat engine is directly related to the reversibility of its processes. A heat engine operating on a completely reversible cycle (e.g., the Carnot cycle) achieves the maximum possible efficiency for given temperature limits. Real heat engines, which involve irreversible processes, always have lower efficiencies. The difference between the theoretical maximum (reversible) efficiency and the actual (irreversible) efficiency quantifies the impact of irreversibilities in the system.
4. How do reversible and irreversible processes affect the calculation of thermodynamic potentials?
Thermodynamic potentials (e.g., Gibbs free energy, Helmholtz free energy) are state functions, meaning their change depends only on initial and final states, not the path. However, the way we calculate these changes can differ for reversible and irreversible processes. For reversible processes, we can use simple relationships involving work and heat. For irreversible processes, we often need to consider the reversible path between the same states and account for additional entropy generation.
5. Can you explain the concept of path dependence in thermodynamic processes?
Path dependence refers to the idea that certain thermodynamic quantities, such as work and heat, depend on the specific path taken between initial and final states, rather than just the states themselves. Reversible processes are path-independent for state functions like internal energy and entropy, but path-dependent for process functions like work and heat. Irreversible processes are always path-dependent, emphasizing the importance of considering the entire process, not just end points.
6. What is a polytropic process?
A polytropic process is a thermodynamic process in which the relationship between pressure and volume follows the equation PVⁿ = constant, where n is the polytropic index. This process encompasses various specific processes, including isothermal (n=1), isobaric (n=0), isochoric (n=∞), and adiabatic (n=γ, ratio of specific heats) processes. Polytropic processes provide a generalized framework for analyzing thermodynamic systems under different conditions.
7. What is the significance of the polytropic index (n) in a polytropic process?
The polytropic index (n) in the equation PVⁿ = constant characterizes the nature of the polytropic process. It determines how pressure, volume, and temperature change relative to each other. Different values of n correspond to specific processes: n=0 (isobaric), n=1 (isothermal), n=γ (adiabatic), n=∞ (isochoric). The index allows for a unified analysis of various thermodynamic processes and helps in understanding heat transfer and work done during these processes.
8. How do polytropic processes relate to the ideal gas law?
Polytropic processes are closely related to the ideal gas law (PV = nRT). The polytropic equation PVⁿ = constant can be derived from the ideal gas law by considering how temperature changes during the process. Different values of the polytropic index n correspond to different constraints on the system (e.g., constant temperature, pressure, or volume). This relationship allows us to use the ideal gas law framework to analyze a wide range of thermodynamic processes, making polytropic processes a powerful tool in thermodynamics.
9. How do polytropic processes help in analyzing real gas behavior?
Polytropic processes provide a flexible framework for analyzing real gas behavior:
10. What is the significance of the Carnot cycle in understanding reversible processes?
The Carnot cycle is a theoretical thermodynamic cycle consisting of two isothermal and two adiabatic reversible processes. Its significance lies in several key areas:
11. What is a reversible process in thermodynamics?
A reversible process is an idealized thermodynamic process that can be reversed without leaving any net change in the system or surroundings. It occurs infinitely slowly, allowing the system to maintain equilibrium at each step. While not achievable in reality, reversible processes serve as important theoretical concepts for understanding maximum efficiency and ideal behavior in thermodynamic systems.
12. Why are reversible processes important in thermodynamics, even though they're impossible in reality?
Reversible processes are crucial in thermodynamics because they represent the ideal, most efficient way a process can occur. They serve as a theoretical limit for real processes, allowing us to calculate maximum efficiencies, understand the direction of spontaneous changes, and develop fundamental thermodynamic relationships. By comparing real processes to reversible ones, we can quantify inefficiencies and work towards optimizing real-world systems.
13. What is the difference between a quasi-static process and a reversible process?
While often used interchangeably, quasi-static and reversible processes are not exactly the same:
14. Why is it impossible to achieve a truly reversible process in reality?
Truly reversible processes are impossible in reality due to several factors:
15. How does the concept of reversibility relate to the Second Law of Thermodynamics?
The concept of reversibility is intimately connected to the Second Law of Thermodynamics. The Second Law states that the entropy of an isolated system always increases for irreversible processes and remains constant for reversible processes. This law essentially defines the "arrow of time" in thermodynamics, explaining why certain processes occur spontaneously in one direction but not in reverse. Reversible processes represent the limiting case where entropy change is zero, serving as a theoretical boundary between allowed and forbidden processes under the Second Law.
16. Can a process be reversible in one direction but irreversible in the other?
No, a process cannot be reversible in one direction and irreversible in the other. By definition, a reversible process must be reversible in both directions without leaving any net change in the system or surroundings. If a process is irreversible in one direction, it will also be irreversible when attempted in reverse. This concept highlights the symmetry required for true reversibility and underscores why all real processes are, to some degree, irreversible.
17. How does the work done in a reversible process compare to that in an irreversible process between the same initial and final states?
For a given change in state, the work done in a reversible process is always greater than (or equal to) the work done in an irreversible process. This is because reversible processes are the most efficient way to perform work, while irreversible processes involve energy dissipation. The difference in work between reversible and irreversible processes quantifies the inefficiency or "lost work" in the irreversible case. This principle is crucial in understanding the limitations and potential improvements in real-world thermodynamic systems.
18. What role do reversible processes play in defining thermodynamic temperature scales?
Reversible processes play a crucial role in defining absolute thermodynamic temperature scales, particularly in the concept of the Kelvin scale. The efficiency of a reversible heat engine operating between two temperatures is used to define the ratio of these temperatures on the Kelvin scale. This approach, independent of any particular substance, provides a universal definition of temperature. The use of reversible processes ensures that the temperature scale is consistent and theoretically sound, forming the basis for all thermodynamic calculations.
19. How does the concept of reversibility apply to phase changes?
In the context of phase changes, reversibility refers to the ability to transition between phases without hysteresis or supersaturation. A truly reversible phase change would occur at the exact equilibrium temperature and pressure, with both phases coexisting in perfect equilibrium. In reality, most phase changes involve some degree of irreversibility due to factors like surface tension, nucleation barriers, and heat transfer limitations. Understanding the reversibility of phase changes is crucial in fields like materials science and chemical engineering.
20. What is the relationship between reversibility and equilibrium in thermodynamic processes?
Reversibility and equilibrium are closely related concepts in thermodynamics:
21. How does the concept of available work relate to reversible and irreversible processes?
Available work, also known as exergy, is the maximum useful work that can be extracted from a system as it reaches equilibrium with its surroundings. It's closely tied to reversibility:
22. What is the importance of understanding polytropic processes in engineering applications?
Understanding polytropic processes is crucial in engineering for several reasons:
23. How do reversible and irreversible processes affect the calculation of entropy?
The calculation of entropy changes differs for reversible and irreversible processes:
24. What is the significance of the polytropic efficiency in real compression processes?
Polytropic efficiency is a key concept in analyzing real compression processes:
25. How does the concept of reversibility apply to chemical reactions?
Reversibility in chemical reactions refers to the ability of a reaction to proceed in both forward and reverse directions:
26. What is the relationship between the polytropic index and the heat capacity ratio in ideal gases?
The relationship between the polytropic index (n) and the heat capacity ratio (γ) in ideal gases is:
27. How do reversible and irreversible processes affect the calculation of thermodynamic efficiencies?
Reversible and irreversible processes significantly impact the calculation of thermodynamic efficiencies:
28. What is the significance of the polytropic equation of state in gas dynamics?
The polytropic equation of state (PVⁿ = constant) is significant in gas dynamics for several reasons:
29. How does the concept of reversibility relate to the maximum work theorem?
The maximum work theorem is closely tied to the concept of reversibility:

Articles

Back to top