Contract of Bailment and pledge

Pledge and bailment contracts differ from one another. The conveyance of commodities from one person to another for a purpose is referred to as bailment in section 148 of The Indian Contract Act, of 1872. When this goal is achieved, the person who received the commodities returns them or disposes of them in another way per the person who delivered them.

CLAT 2025: 10 Free Mock Tests | Legal Maxims | Landmark Judgements | PYQs

CUET BA LLB 2025:  Legal Studies ebook | 5 Free Mock Tests

MH CET LAW 2025: 10 Free Mock Tests | Legal Reasoning Practice Questions

Monthly Legal Current Affairs:  August’24 | July’24 | June’24

This Story also Contains

1. What is a Bailment Contract?
2. Contract of Pledge
3. Recognising the Differences Between Bailment and Pledge
4. Conclusion

Transferring an item for a specified reason, such as safekeeping, is known as bailment. Transferring a good as security for a debt is known as a pledge. If the obligation is not paid back, the pledgee has the sole right to sell the good. The concepts of bailment and pledge is described under the preview of Legal studies.

What is a Bailment Contract?

• The term 'Bailment' originates from the French word 'Baillier', which means to deliver.

• Section 148 of the Indian Contract Act, of 1872 defines "bailment" as "the delivery of goods by one person to another for some purpose, upon a contract that they shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed of under the directions of the person delivering them."

• The individual who delivers the products is known as the 'Bailor', whereas the person who receives the commodities for a specified purpose is known as the 'Bailee'.

• It is a specific sort of contract governed by Chapter IX (Sections 148-171) of the Indian Contract Act, of 1872.

Essential Components of a Valid Bailment

The Contract of Bailment has several elements; a few of the more important ones are discussed below:

Agreement between Bailor and Bailee

The bailor and bailee must have reached an agreement. This agreement may be expressed or assumed. In some cases, a bailment may be required by law, such as when a missing item is found.

In the case of, Kavita Trehan vs. Balsara Hygiene Products Ltd., the Supreme Court ruled that the surrender of possession to the bailee is a sine qua non (necessary condition) of bailment.

Delivery of Goods

In bailment, the commodities must be delivered to the bailee. It is fundamental to the bailment agreement. The custody of commodities must be transferred freely and in line with the contract.

Delivery might be of two types:

• Actual delivery: Delivering an automobile to a workshop dealer for repair is considered an actual delivery.

• Constructive delivery: Delivering a car key to a workshop dealer for repair is considered constructive delivery.

In the case of the State of Gujarat against Memon Mahomed Haji Hasam, the Supreme Court ruled that bailment cannot be established without a contract. Only if a bailment is based on a contract is it subject to the Contracts Act.

Exception: Lost Goods Found

When the lost commodities are discovered by a third party or a stranger, the founder of the goods serves as the bailee.

Duties of the Finder:

• To keep the items secure.

• Do not use these products for personal use.

• Make appropriate attempts to locate the true owner of the products.

• Make certain that the things are handed to their rightful owner once discovered.

Rights of the Finder

• To be reimbursed for the expenditures and effort required to keep things safe and locate the owner.

• According to Section 168, items must be sold if they are in perishable condition.

• The owner couldn't be located.

Delivery for some Purpose

The transfer of commodities from the bailor to the bailee must be for a particular purpose. Sections 153 and 154 provide that the bailment contract may be cancelled if the bailee acts inconsistently or makes unauthorised use of the commodities. The specific objective is critical, and both parties must follow the terms of the agreement.

For example, A brings his automobile to B's garage for washing.

Return of Goods

After the reason for which the commodities were bailed is fulfilled, the bailee must return them to the bailor. The method and manner of return will be as specified in the contract or by the bailor.

Under Section 160: "The bailee must return or deliver according to the bailor's directions, the goods bailed, without demand, as soon as the time for which they were bailed has expired, or the purpose for which they were bailed has been accomplished."

Role of the Bailor and the Bailee

The bailor and bailee must comply with certain requirements outlined in the bailment contract. A couple of the essential points are listed below.

Duties of the Bailor

The bailor's tasks are briefly described below:

• To reveal flaws in Goods: The bailor must notify the bailee of any flaws in the goods. If the bailor fails to do so, he is accountable to the bailee for any losses resulting from such failure.

• To Pay Required and Exceptional Costs: The bailor is obligated to reimburse the bailee for any required and unusual fees made to safeguard the commodities bailed.

• To Indemnify the Bailee for all Losses: According to Section 159 of the Indian Contract Act, the bailor is obligated to reimburse the bailee for any damage suffered if the bailor requests his goods before the agreed-upon deadline. According to Section 164, the bailee may also recover losses from the bailor if the bailor wilfully bails goods with a defective title.

• To collect Bailed Goods: The bailor must retrieve his goods after the period for which they were bailed has passed. If the bailor fails to collect the items by the end of the bailment period, he will be accountable for any damages suffered by the bailee.

Role of the Bailee

The Contract of Bailment specifies several tasks that Bailey must do; a few of the essential aspects are listed below.

• Take Proper Care of the Products: According to Section 151 of the Indian Contract Act of 1872, the bailee is responsible for the commodities bailed to him as if they were their own. However, section 152 states that in the absence of a particular Contract, the bailee is not accountable for the loss or collapse of the commodities bailed provided he has taken care of the goods under the Contract.

• To use the items for permitted purposes exclusively.

• The bailee should utilise the products strictly for the reason specified in the contract. If it is discovered that the products are being used for unlawful purposes, the bailor may declare the entire contract null and invalid. Under the provisions of Section 154, "If the bailee makes any use of the goods bailed which is not according to the conditions of the bailment, he is liable to make compensation to the bailor for any damage arising to the goods from or during such use of them."

• Keep the bailed goods separate: The bailee must ensure that the items are safely returned to the bailor. He is required to store the things separately.

1. Section 155: It allows the bailee to combine his own and the bailor's goods with the bailor's approval. In this instance, both the bailor and the bailee must have an interest in the mixture generated.

2. Section 156: States that if the bailee mixes the commodities without the bailor's agreement and the items may be separated, the bailee is liable for the costs of partition or division, as well as any damages incurred as a result of the mixing.

3. Section 157: If the bailee combines the commodities without the bailor's authorisation and they cannot be divided in this instance, the bailee is obligated to cover the harm and compensate the bailor.

Types of Bailment

The following are the many sorts of bailments:

1. Gratuitous Bailment: A bailment in which only one side profits. For example, lending a book to a buddy does not provide you with any reward.

2. Non-gratuitous Bailment: This type of bailment benefits both parties. For example, leaving your automobile at a repair shop benefits both you and the business owner.

3. Constructive Bailment: This sort of bailment occurs when a person discovers missing property and takes care of it.

Contract of Pledge

• In a pledge contract, the items are held as collateral for a debt.

• According to Section 172 of the Indian Contract Act 1872, 'the bailment of the commodities as security for the payment of a debt or the execution of a contract is termed pledge'.

• In this scenario, the bailor is referred to as the pawnor, and the bailee is the pawnee.

• It is regulated by Chapter IX (Sections 172–181) of the Indian Contract Act, of 1872.

Parties Involved in Pledge

The following parties participate in the pledge:

1. The Pledgor is the individual who owns the item and transfers it to the pledgee. The pledgor utilises the asset as collateral for a debt or obligation.

2. The individual who obtains the good from the pledgor is the Pledgee. Until the debtor settles the obligation, the pledgee is the owner of the good. The pledgee is entitled to sell the good if the debtor is unable to make payments.

3. The one who is in debt or has an obligation is the Debtor. The good is returned to the pledgor by the pledgee upon the debtor's redemption of the obligation. The pledgee may sell the good if the debtor is unable to make payments.

Rights of Pawnee and Pawnor

The act of pledging goods as collateral for the payment of a debt or the fulfilment of a guarantee is known as a Pawn. The bailee is referred to as the pledgee, while the bailor is referred to as the pledger or pawnor. This procedure is known as a pledge by non-owners or the pledge legislation. For both parties, the pledge agreement is enforceable.

Rights of Pawnor

Section 173: Right to Retain Merchandise

The pledged items are subject to the pawnee's retention rights until the loan's maturity date. For the duration of the obligation and any costs associated with the preservation of such goods, he will keep them. He does, however, also reserve the power to use a wholly express lien on goods.

Section 174: Right to Retain Ensuant Advances

It is always likely that, unless a contract expressly states otherwise, the adult's right to keep the promised goods also includes the money they gave to another adult on the day of the pledge.

Section 175: Right to Extraordinary Expenses

The pawnee also has the right to demand reimbursement for any out-of-the-ordinary costs he incurs to protect the goods pledged. He may only file a lawsuit for sickness of expenditures; he cannot keep the items.

Section 178 A: Right Against the True Owner

The contract is still in effect even if the pledger's title to the pledged goods is deemed to be faulty and possession is acquired under a revocable agreement. If the adult performs honourably, he has the right to accumulate a reasonable claim to the promised goods.

The pawnor has the following rights if the pawnee makes any illegal sales of goods pledged without providing the pawnor with the appropriate notice and time:

• The ability to start a lawsuit to recover items by establishing a debt.

• The ability to claim losses and damages at the bottom of conversion.

Rights of a Pawnee

1. The right to have the products returned: Once the promise is kept or the loan and interest are paid back, the pawnor has the right to have the items returned.

2. Possession of the Items Until Payment: The Pawnee is entitled to retain the pledged goods until the obligation, interest, and any expenses associated with the products are paid in full. For instance, Mr. X guarantees his gold jewels in exchange for bank loans. In this situation, the bank is fully entitled to retain the gold embellishments for the credit amount alteration and to install the premium that was collected on the advance amount.

3. The entitlement to debt redemption: The chosen period is allotted for fulfilling a commitment or paying off debt. When the pawnor fails to fulfil a commitment or pay back a loan, he has the right to redeem the pledged goods before their sale, although he is still responsible for covering any associated costs.

4. The entitlement to uphold and safeguard merchandise: The adult has the right to see that the pledgee is appropriately preserving and caring for the promised items. Pawnee is entitled to seek compensation for the extraordinary expenses incurred. In any event, he is unable to carry goods in this situation.

5. The Ordinary Debtor's Rights: The pawnor has rights as well, rights granted to him by several laws designed for the protection of borrowers, much like those of a regular debtor.

6. Ability to File a Suit: The Pawnee is entitled to keep the promised goods as security while filing a lawsuit to collect the obligation. Because of him, he is entitled to sue for the offer of goods pledged and payment instalments.

7. Possession of the Right to Sell: The right to sell the goods is granted by the pawnee after providing the pawnor with reasonable notice and time. After the pawnor offers such things, the pawnee, if any, may claim for inadequacy. In addition, the pawnee is required to return any excess product discount to the pawn.

Important Components of a Contract Of Pledge

A pledge has the qualities listed below:

• Transfer of Possession: When a promise is made, the pledgor gives the pledgee ownership of the good.

• Goal: Securing a debt or obligation is the main goal of a pledge.

• Return of Good: After the debtor pays back the loan, the pledgee gives the good back to the pledgor.

• Right to Sell: The pledgee is entitled to sell the good if the debtor defaults on the loan.

• Risk of Loss: The pledgor bears the risk of loss in a commitment.

• There Are Three Parties: The pledgor, the pledgee, and the debtor are the three parties involved in a pledge.

Kinds of Pledge

The various kinds of commitments are as follows:

1. Pawn: In a pawn, the borrower (pawnor) pledges something to the lender (pawnee) in exchange for a loan.

2. Hypothecation: In this kind of pledge, the asset is still owned by the borrower, but in the event of loan failure, the lender is granted the right to sell the item.

3. Lien: Under this kind of commitment, the asset is subject to the lender's ownership until the debt is repaid.

Recognising the Differences Between Bailment and Pledge

Here are some frequent distinctions between a pledge and a contract of bailment:

Conclusion

Pledge and bailment contracts are a broad and important subject. Not all bailment contracts are pledge contracts, but all pledge contracts are contracts of bailment. The interests of the parties to the contract are safeguarded by the pledge and bailment arrangements. It also provides a structure for the Contract and outlines the rights and obligations of the bailor and bailee as well as the pawnor and pawnee. For the Contract of Bailment and Pledge to be enforceable by law, it must also meet the requirements of a legitimate contract.