Rain-man Problem
The Rain Man Problem A very simple, dramatically interesting problem in introductory physics. It explains how the motion of rain is relative to a moving man. You are walking home in a rainstorm and want to understand why you get wetter under some circumstances than others. Explain how the angle and speed of rain hitting you vary as a function of your motion. This problem brings in concepts of relative motion, where in this case, it is the motion of the rain and the person combined. It shows us how the faster you move the more rain will be encountered from the front. By knowing this, it helps us make decisions on how best to move in the rain so we do not get as wet and it is a good example of many of the principles of motion and direction.
- What is Rain man problem?
- How to Solve Rain Main Problem
- Solved Examples Besed On Rain Main Problem
- Summary
In this article, we will cover the concept of Rain's main problem. This concept falls under the broader category of kinematics which is a crucial chapter in Class 11 Physics. It is not only essential for board exams but also for competitive exams like the Joint Entrance Examination (JEE Main), National Eligibility Entrance Test (NEET), and other entrance exams such as SRMJEE, BITSAT, WBJEE, BCECE and more. Over the last ten years of the JEE Main exam (from 2013 to 2023), a total of one question has been asked on this concept.
What is Rain man problem?
The rainman problem is simply a physics concept which investigates how the direction and velocity of rain seem to change contingent on your motion. Imagine standing still in the rain; it falls perfectly straight down on you. But when you start walking or running, it appears to fall upon you from a completely different angle. This is because, with your motion, an additional horizontal component has been added to the perpendicular motion of the rain. The problem goes a long way to explaining relative motion, showing how the apparent direction of rain depends on your speed and heading. This concept can easily be made practical daily when walking, driving, or cycling in the rain, showing you how to stay drier by walking in a certain way.
Terminology
$
\begin{aligned}
& \overrightarrow{V_m}=\text { velocity of man in the horizontal direction } \\
& \overrightarrow{V_r}=\text { velocity of rain w.r.t ground } \\
& \overrightarrow{V_{r m}}=\text { velocity of rain w.r.t man }
\end{aligned}
$
The velocity of rain w.r.t man is given by
$
\overrightarrow{V_{r m}}=\overrightarrow{V_r}-\overrightarrow{V_m}
$
For a Special case when the Velocity of rain falling vertically
Then,
$
\tan \theta=\frac{V_m}{V_r}
$
Where $\theta=$ angle which relative velocity of rain with respect to man makes with the vertical
Recommended Topic Video
How to Solve Rain Main Problem
To solve a rain-man problem, which is a type of relative velocity problem in physics, follow these steps:
Problem Explanation
In a rain-man problem, the goal is to calculate either the angle at which a person (or object) should hold an umbrella or the velocity of the rain relative to the person. This typically involves understanding the velocities of the rain relative to the ground and the person relative to the ground.
Step-by-Step Solution
1. Identify Given Quantities
- Velocity of the rain with respect to the ground: $v_r$
- Velocity of the man with respect to the ground: $v_m$
- Angle at which the rain is falling (relative to the vertical direction): $\theta_r$
2. Set Up the Coordinate System
- Assume the ground as the reference point.
- Let the rain's velocity $v_r$ have two components: vertical $\left(v_{r_y}\right)$ and horizontal $\left(v_{r_x}\right)$.
3. Break Down Velocities into Components
- If the rain is falling at an angle, decompose its velocity:
- Vertical component of rain's velocity: $v_{r_y}=v_r \cos \left(\theta_r\right)$
- Horizontal component of rain's velocity: $v_{r_x}=v_r \sin \left(\theta_r\right)$
4. Relative Velocity of Rain with Respect to the Man
The relative velocity of the rain with respect to the man is calculated using the vector sum of the rain's velocity and the man's velocity. Since the man is moving horizontally (say with velocity $v_m$ ):
- Horizontal relative velocity: $v_{r_{\text {relative }_x}}=v_{r_x}-v_m$ component)
5. Calculate the Resultant Velocity of Rain Relative to the Man
The resultant relative velocity can be found using the Pythagorean theorem:
5. Calculate the Resultant Velocity of Rain Relative to the Man
The resultant relative velocity can be found using the Pythagorean theorem:
6. Find the Angle at which the Man Should Hold the Umbrella
The angle $\theta_{\text {relative }}$ at which the man should hold the umbrella (relative to the vertical) can be found using:
$\tan \left(\theta_{\text {relative }}\right)=\frac{v_{r_{\text {relative }, z}}}{v_{r_{\text {relative }, y}}}$
Solving for $\theta_{\text {relative }}$ :
Solved Examples Besed On Rain Main Problem
Example 1: Rain is falling vertically at a speed of 35 m/s. The wind started blowing after some time with a speed of 12 m/s in an east-to-west direction. In which direction should a boy waiting at a bus stop hold his umbrella with the vertical?
1) $\sin ^{-1}\left(\frac{12}{35}\right)$
2) $\cos ^{-1}\left(\frac{12}{35}\right)$
3) $\tan ^{-1}\left(\frac{12}{35}\right)$
4) $\cot ^{-1}\left(\frac{12}{35}\right)$
Solution:
Given-
velocity of rain - $\left|\overrightarrow{v_r}\right|=35 \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}$
velocity of wind $\left|\overrightarrow{v_w}\right|=12 \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}$
the velocity of rain concerning the wind-
$
\overrightarrow{v_{r w}}=\overrightarrow{v_r}-\overrightarrow{v_w}
$
vector diagram in vertical plane-
The man at rest will hold an umbrella opposite to the velocity of rain when wind is not present. In case there is wind blowing, the umbrella should be opposite to the direction of the velocity of rain concerning the wind, as shown in the figure.
$\begin{aligned} & \quad \tan \theta=\frac{V_w}{V_r}=\frac{12}{35} \\ & \therefore \theta=\tan ^{-1} \frac{12}{35}\end{aligned}$
Example 2: Rain is falling vertically downward with a velocity of 3kmph. A boy walks in the rain with a velocity of 4 mph. Traindropsops appear to be falling on the boy with a velocity (in kmph) of
1 )5
2) 3
3) 4
4) 1
Solution:
Given-
Assuming the vertical downward direction to be along y direction and horizontal direction to be x direction.
velocity of rain $=3 \hat{j}$
the velocity of the oy $=4 \hat{i}$
$
\begin{aligned}
& \vec{V}_{R B}=\vec{V}_R-\vec{V}_B \\
& =3 \hat{j}-4 \hat{i} \\
& \left|\vec{V}_{R B}\right|=\sqrt{(3)^2+(4)^2}=5 \mathrm{kmph}
\end{aligned}
$
Hence, the answer is option (1).
Example 3: When a car is at rest, its driver sees raindrops falling on it vertically. When driving the car with speed $v$, he sees that raindrops are coming at an angle of $60^{\circ}$ from the horizontal. On further increasing the car's speed to $(1+\beta) v$, this angle changes to $45^{\circ}$. The value is close to :
1) 50
2) 41
3) 37
4) 73
Solution:
Rain is falling vertically downwards.
$
\overrightarrow{\mathrm{v}}_{r / \mathrm{m}}=\overrightarrow{\mathrm{v}}_{\mathrm{r}}-\overrightarrow{\mathrm{v}}_m
$
$\begin{aligned} & \tan 60^{\circ}=\frac{\mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{r}}}{\mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{m}}}=\sqrt{3} \\ & \mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{r}}=\mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{m}} \sqrt{3}=\mathrm{v} \sqrt{3} \\ & \text { Now, } \mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{m}}=(1+\mathrm{B}) \mathrm{v} \\ & \text { and } \theta=45^{\circ} \\ & \tan 45=\frac{\mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{c}}}{\mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{m}}}=1 \\ & \mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{r}}=\mathrm{v}_{\mathrm{m}} \\ & \mathrm{v} \sqrt{3}=(1+\beta) \mathrm{v} \\ & \sqrt{3}=1+\beta \\ & \Rightarrow \beta=\sqrt{3}-1=0.73 \\ & 100 \beta=73\end{aligned}$
Example 4: A man walking at a speed of 4 km/hr finds the raindrops falling vertically downwards. When the man increases his speed to 8 km/hr he finds that the raindrops are falling making an angle of 30 degrees with the vertical. find the speed of the raindrops
1) 4 m/s
2) 5 m/s
3) 8 m/s
4) 10 m/s
Solution:
$\overrightarrow{V_m}=$ velocity of man in the horizontal direction
$
\begin{aligned}
& \vec{V}_r=\text { velocity of rain w.r.t ground } \\
& \overrightarrow{V_{r m}}=\text { velocity of rain w.r.t man }
\end{aligned}
$
The velocity of rain w.r.t man is given by
$
\begin{aligned}
\overrightarrow{V_{r m}}=\overrightarrow{V_r}-\overrightarrow{V_m} \\
\text { As } \overrightarrow{V_{r m}}=\overrightarrow{V_r}-\overrightarrow{V_m}
\end{aligned}
$
Initially
$
V_m=4 \vec{i}
$
As $V_{r m}$ is vertically downwards and perpendicular to $V_m$
$
\tan \phi=\tan 30=\frac{4}{x}
$
So from figure $x=4 \sqrt{3}$
And $\mathrm{x}=$ vertical component of $V_r$
From the figure, the Horizontal component of $V_r=4 \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}$
$
\text { So } V_r=\sqrt{4^2+(4 \sqrt{3})^2}=8 \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}
$
Example 5: A man wearing a hat of extended length 12 cm is running in rain falling vertically downwards with a speed of 10 m/s. The maximum speed with which man can run, so that raindrops do not fall on his face (the length of his face below the extended part of the hat is 16 cm) will be : (please give your answer in m/s)
1) 7.5
2)13.33
3)10
4)0
Solution:
for Rain-Man Problem
$
\tan \theta=\frac{V_m}{V_r}
$
$\theta=$ angle which relative velocity of rain with
respect to man makes with the vertical
- wherein
$\vec{V}_r=$ velocity of rain falling vertically
$\overrightarrow{V_m}=$ velocity of man in the horizontal direction
$
V_{R / G(x)}=0, V_{R / G(y)}=10 \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}
$
Let, the velocity of man $=V$
$
\tan \theta=\frac{16}{12}=\frac{4}{3}
$
then, $\quad V_{R / \operatorname{man}}=V_{\text {(opposite to man) }}$
For the required conditions:
$
\tan \theta \frac{V_{R / M(y)}}{V_{R / M(x)}}=\frac{10}{V}=\frac{4}{3}
$
$\begin{aligned}
&\Rightarrow V=\frac{10 \times 3}{4}=7.5\\
&\text { Hence, the answer is } 7.5 \text {. }
\end{aligned}$
Summary
The Rain Man Problem is a physics puzzle that helps to understand how getting wet in the rain depends on movement. One of the major examples of how getting wet in the course of walking or running changes is the direction and speed of the raindrops hitting you. When you are standing still doing nothing, the rain is falling vertically straight on you. The impression is that, in the process of walking or running, the rain comes at an angle, say, at an angle of 45°, and you might get more rain on the front.
The relative motion learning from such a problem is the way movements are combined. You move faster and you run into more rain from the front, so you get wetter at that spot. The potential of that idea comes into play in the real world in how to decide between walking and running in the rain too to become less wet. We make out from such practical applications that the principles of physics are ingrained in our daily routines in such a way that they help one understand how a person moves about natural phenomena.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Relative velocity is crucial in this problem. It determines how the rain appears to fall from the perspective of the moving person. The relative velocity is the vector sum of the rain's velocity and the negative of the person's velocity, affecting the apparent angle and speed of the rainfall.
Vector addition is essential for solving this problem. It allows us to combine the velocity vectors of the rain and the person to determine the relative velocity of the rain as seen by the person. This helps in calculating the apparent angle of rainfall and the rate at which raindrops hit the person.
Wind speed adds a horizontal component to the rain's velocity. This changes the effective angle of rainfall relative to the ground and the person. As wind speed increases, it can significantly alter the optimal strategy for minimizing exposure to rain, potentially making it more beneficial to move slower or in a different direction.
Common assumptions include: uniform rainfall (constant rate and droplet size), constant wind speed and direction, neglecting air resistance on the person, and assuming the person moves at a constant velocity. These simplifications make the problem more manageable while still providing valuable insights.
The "rain vector" represents the velocity of falling raindrops, including both vertical (due to gravity) and horizontal (due to wind) components. Understanding this vector is crucial for determining how the rain interacts with a moving person and calculating the optimal strategy for minimizing wetness.
The "Rain-man Problem" is a classic physics problem that deals with the motion of a person walking in rain. It explores how the relative motion between the person, rain, and ground affects the path of raindrops as seen by the person walking.
Rain intensity refers to the volume of water falling per unit area per unit time. In the Rain-man Problem, it affects how quickly a person gets wet. Higher rain intensity means more raindrops per second, increasing the rate at which a person becomes wet, regardless of their motion.
The cross-sectional area of a person (frontal area when walking/running and top area) directly affects how much rain they intercept. A larger frontal area will collect more rain when moving forward, while a larger top area will collect more rain falling vertically. This is why umbrellas are effective - they increase the top area while reducing the exposed body area.
Contrary to popular belief, running doesn't necessarily make you wetter. The amount of rain you encounter depends on your speed and the rain's angle. Running can reduce your time in the rain, potentially keeping you drier overall, but it may increase the rate at which you collide with raindrops from the front.
The critical angle is the angle of rainfall at which running no longer provides an advantage over walking in terms of staying dry. It depends on the ratio of the person's height to their stride length. Understanding this angle helps determine when changing speed will or won't be beneficial.
The angle of rainfall, determined by the combination of the rain's vertical fall and horizontal wind speed, affects the best approach. If rain is falling straight down, running helps minimize exposure time. However, if there's a strong horizontal wind component, the optimal speed may be different and could even involve walking in some cases.
A person's height affects their total exposed surface area and the time they spend in the rain. Taller individuals have a larger vertical surface area exposed to horizontal rain components but may cover the same distance in fewer steps. This can influence the optimal strategy for minimizing wetness.
In more sophisticated analyses, air resistance can affect both the person's motion and the raindrops' trajectories. It can limit the person's maximum speed and cause raindrops to deviate from straight-line paths, especially in strong winds. This adds complexity but can provide more accurate results for real-world scenarios.
Stride length is important because it affects the relationship between a person's speed and their time spent in the rain. A longer stride allows for faster travel with fewer steps, potentially reducing overall rain exposure. However, it may also increase the frontal area exposed to rain with each step.
While not immediately obvious, the concept of work is relevant to the Rain-man Problem. The "work" done by the rain on the person can be thought of as the energy transferred by the raindrops upon impact. This is related to the kinetic energy of the drops relative to the person, which depends on their relative velocity - a key component of the problem.
The principle of least action, while typically used in more advanced physics, can be creatively applied to the Rain-man Problem. In this context, the "action" could be defined as the total amount of rain encountered. The principle would then suggest that the optimal path and speed would minimize this total rain exposure, subject to constraints like starting and ending positions.
Terminal velocity is the maximum speed a raindrop can attain due to air resistance. In detailed analyses, considering the terminal velocity of raindrops can affect calculations, especially for very small droplets or in strong winds. It influences the actual trajectory and impact speed of raindrops, potentially altering the optimal strategy for staying dry.
Momentum transfer occurs when raindrops collide with the person. While often neglected in basic treatments, considering momentum transfer can provide insights into the force exerted by the rain and how it might affect the person's motion, especially in heavy rain or strong winds. This can be particularly relevant for analyzing the impact of rain on fast-moving objects like vehicles.
While not typically associated with introductory problems, the Rain-man scenario can be viewed in terms of phase space. The state of the system (person + rain) at any moment can be described by position and velocity coordinates in a multi-dimensional phase space. This perspective can be useful for advanced statistical treatments of rain distribution and motion.
While unconventional, the method of images concept can be creatively adapted to the Rain-man Problem. Just as image charges are used to simplify electric field calculations, one could imagine "image rain sources" to account for the effect of wind or the person's motion on the apparent source of raindrops. This analogy can help visualize and possibly simplify complex rain field analyses.
The Reynolds number, which characterizes the flow regime of fluids, can be relevant in advanced analyses of the Rain-man Problem. It could be applied to understand the air flow around the person or the behavior of raindrops. A high Reynolds number might indicate turbulent air flow, affecting raindrop trajectories and the person's interaction with both air and rain.
Drag coefficients can be incorporated to model air resistance more accurately. This is relevant both for the person's motion (especially at higher speeds) and for the raindrops' trajectories. Different drag coefficients for various body positions or raindrop sizes can lead to more nuanced analyses of optimal strategies for minimizing wetness in different conditions.
Conservation of energy in the Rain-man Problem can be considered in terms of the kinetic energy of raindrops before and after impact with the person. The energy transferred upon impact contributes to wetting the person. Additionally, the person's kinetic energy as they move through the rain field and the work done against air resistance can be analyzed using energy conservation principles.
Flux, in this context, refers to the rate at which rain passes through a given area. It's calculated as the product of rain velocity, rain density, and the area through which it passes. Understanding flux helps quantify how much rain a person encounters based on their motion and the rain's characteristics.
Considering both top and front surfaces is crucial because rain can hit a person from above (due to its vertical velocity component) and from the front (due to the person's forward motion and any horizontal wind). The total amount of rain encountered is the sum of what hits both surfaces.
Changing direction can significantly affect rain exposure, especially in windy conditions. Moving perpendicular to the wind direction may reduce frontal exposure but increase the time spent in the rain. The optimal path often involves finding a balance between minimizing time in the rain and reducing the effective rainfall rate.
As a person's speed increases, the apparent angle of rainfall becomes more horizontal from their perspective. This is due to the relative motion between the person and the rain. At higher speeds, more rain appears to come from the front, potentially increasing frontal exposure.
The Rain-man Problem is a perfect example of relative motion. It demonstrates how the motion of one object (the person) affects the perceived motion of another (the rain). This illustrates the principle that motion is relative and depends on the frame of reference of the observer.
To calculate the relative velocity of rain, subtract the person's velocity vector from the rain's velocity vector. If v_r is the rain's velocity and v_p is the person's velocity, the relative velocity v_rel = v_r - v_p. This vector subtraction gives both the magnitude and direction of the rain's motion from the person's perspective.
Time minimization is a key strategy in the Rain-man Problem. The idea is that by reducing the time spent in the rain, you can potentially reduce overall exposure. However, this must be balanced against the increased rate of frontal rain interception that comes with higher speeds.
Raindrop size affects the terminal velocity of the drops and their interaction with wind. Larger drops fall faster and are less influenced by wind, while smaller drops are more easily carried by air currents. This can change the effective angle and speed of rainfall, influencing the optimal strategy for staying dry.
The wetness rate is the rate at which a person accumulates water while moving through rain. It's a crucial concept as it combines the effects of rainfall intensity, relative motion, and exposed surface area. Minimizing the wetness rate is often the goal when solving Rain-man Problems.
The principle of superposition applies in the Rain-man Problem when considering the total amount of rain encountered. The rain hitting the top of the person (due to vertical fall) and the rain hitting the front (due to relative horizontal motion) can be calculated separately and then added together to find the total exposure.
The solid angle concept helps in understanding how much of the "rain field" a person intercepts. As a person moves, they sweep out a volume in space-time. The solid angle this volume subtends at a point in the rain field represents the fraction of total rainfall the person encounters, helping quantify their exposure.
Vector decomposition is crucial for breaking down the motion of rain and the person into manageable components. By separating velocities into vertical and horizontal components, it becomes easier to analyze the relative motion, calculate the apparent angle of rainfall, and determine the rain flux through different surfaces.
The Rain-man Problem beautifully illustrates how changing the frame of reference affects the perceived motion of objects. From the ground's frame, rain falls at an angle determined by its vertical and horizontal velocities. However, from the moving person's frame, the rain appears to fall at a different angle due to relative motion.
The "rain field" concept treats rainfall as a continuous field of droplets in space rather than discrete particles. This approach allows for more sophisticated mathematical treatments, including the use of flux integrals to calculate total rain exposure. It's particularly useful for handling non-uniform rainfall or complex motion paths.
Optimization in the Rain-man Problem involves finding the best strategy (usually in terms of speed and direction) to minimize wetness. This often requires balancing conflicting factors: moving faster reduces time in the rain but increases frontal exposure rate. The optimal solution depends on various parameters like rain angle, wind speed, and the person's dimensions.
The Rain-man Problem is an excellent application of flux in vector calculus. The rain can be modeled as a vector field, and the person's motion creates a surface moving through this field. The total amount of rain encountered is equivalent to the flux of the rain field through the surface swept out by the person's motion.
Dimensional analysis is a powerful tool in the Rain-man Problem. It helps ensure that calculations are consistent and can provide insights into the relationships between variables. For example, it can show that the optimal speed for minimizing wetness must be proportional to the wind speed, guiding the problem-solving approach.
The cross-section concept is crucial in the Rain-man Problem. The person's frontal and top cross-sectional areas determine how much rain they intercept. The effective cross-section changes with the person's orientation relative to the rain's apparent direction, affecting the rate of water accumulation.
Vector dot products are essential in the Rain-man Problem for calculating the rate of rain interception. The dot product of the rain's velocity vector with the normal vector of the person's surface (top or front) gives the flux of rain through that surface. This is key to determining how quickly the person gets wet from different directions.
Path integrals can be used in sophisticated analyses of the Rain-man Problem to calculate total rain exposure for complex paths. Instead of assuming straight-line motion, a path integral allows for curved or arbitrary paths through the rain field. This approach can be useful for optimizing routes in varying wind conditions or around obstacles.
The steady-state assumption is often implicitly used in the Rain-man Problem. It assumes that conditions (rain intensity, wind speed, person's velocity) remain constant over time. This simplification allows for easier analysis but recognizing when this assumption breaks down (e.g., in gusty conditions or when accelerating) is important for more realistic scenarios.
While the Rain-man Problem doesn't involve relativistic speeds, it serves as an excellent introductory example of how different frames of reference perceive motion differently - a key concept in special relativity. The apparent angle of rainfall changing with the person's speed is analogous to more complex relativistic effects like time dilation and length contraction at high velocities.
Considering non-uniform rain distribution adds realism to the Rain-man Problem. In real scenarios, rain intensity and droplet size can vary spatially and temporally. This consideration can lead to more complex optimization problems, where the best path might involve moving through areas of varying rainfall, balancing exposure time against local rain intensity.
Also Read
03 Jul'25 05:44 PM