93 Views

Is mba in abroad worth it or mba in india is better ? With bad academic and zero work experience,on the basis of cat or gmat score what are the chances of securing a top mba college ?


Harshit 30th Nov, 2024
Answers (4)
Nikhil Kumar Rai 10th Dec, 2024

That’s a great question and shows you’re thinking carefully about your future. It's important to consider both options carefully, especially with your background. When considering whether to pursue an MBA abroad or in India, especially with poor academics and no work experience, the decision requires careful evaluation of your goals, financial situation, and career aspirations.

When comparing an MBA in India versus one abroad, there's no definitive winner—it ultimately depends on a student’s aspirations and willingness to invest financially for potentially greater returns. Each option offers its own distinct benefits, which can be better understood through a detailed discussion. Both options have their merits and challenges. Let’s break it down to help you make an informed decision.

What Is the Purpose of an MBA?

An MBA (Master of Business Administration) equips students with:

  • Leadership and management skills: To lead teams and organizations effectively.

  • Strategic thinking abilities : To solve complex business problems.

  • Career advancement opportunities : To secure roles in management, consulting, or entrepreneurship.

  • Networking: To build connections with industry professionals and peers.

The value of an MBA depends heavily on the program's quality, your goals, and the level of effort you put into leveraging its benefits.

MBA Abroad vs. MBA in India: A Comparison

MBA Abroad

Pros:

  1. Global Exposure: Study in a multicultural environment and gain insights into international markets.

  2. Top-Quality Education: Renowned universities provide cutting-edge curriculum and resources.

  3. Networking Opportunities: Build a global professional network.

  4. Higher Earning Potential: Graduates from top programs often secure higher salaries, particularly in developed economies.

  5. Prestige: Degrees from institutions like Harvard, INSEAD, or Wharton carry global recognition and respect.

Cons:

  1. High Cost: Tuition fees and living expenses are substantial. Scholarships are competitive.

  2. Work Visa Challenges: Securing post-MBA work permits can be difficult in some countries.

  3. Work Experience Requirement: Most top MBA programs abroad require 2-5 years of professional experience.

  4. Risk: Without a strong profile, you may not gain admission to top schools, reducing the ROI (return on investment).

Who Is It For?

  • Candidates with strong financial resources.
  • Those aiming for international roles or exposure to global markets.

  • Students with a clear plan for their post-MBA career .

MBA in India

Pros:

  1. Cost-Effective: Tuition fees and living costs are significantly lower than in most foreign programs.

  2. Reputed Institutions: Top Indian MBA programs (e.g., IIMs, ISB, XLRI) are highly regarded, especially for roles in Indian and Asian markets.

  3. Local Relevance: Focus on Indian business contexts and networks.

  4. Shorter Duration: Many MBA programs in India are completed in 1-2 years.

  5. Flexible Entry: Some private universities and tier-2 colleges accept candidates with weaker academics or no work experience.

Cons:

  1. Less Global Exposure: International experience and networks may be limited.

  2. High Competition: Admission to top-tier institutes like IIMs is extremely competitive and requires strong CAT/GMAT scores.

  3. Brand Value: While prestigious in India, Indian MBA degrees may lack global recognition compared to programs abroad.

Who Is It For?

  • Candidates targeting the Indian job market or local companies.

  • Students looking for a cost-effective education with high-quality outcomes.

  • Fresh graduates or those who prefer programs without stringent entry requirements.

Since you mentioned having poor academics and no work experience, both options have specific challenges:

MBA Abroad Challenges :

  • Admission Requirements: Most top-tier schools abroad require a strong academic record and work experience. Without these, securing admission to a reputed institution can be difficult.

  • Cost and ROI: The financial investment is high. Without admission to a top program or a clear plan for career advancement, it may not provide a good return.

MBA in India Challenges

  • Limited Opportunities in Top Programs: Schools like IIMs and ISB value academic consistency and work experience.

  • Lower Exposure: Compared to studying abroad, Indian MBAs may not offer the same level of global exposure.

Conclusion: Based on your current situation, a good approach may be to gain some work experience, improve your academic profile, and then decide whether to pursue an MBA in India or abroad.

Focus on Skills: Irrespective of the choice, focus on acquiring key skills such as leadership, communication, and analytical thinking, which are crucial for a successful career in business.

An MBA is a significant investment in your future, and careful consideration of these factors will help you make an informed decision.

Feel free to reach out if you need further guidance or have more questions!

Prachi Kumari 4th Dec, 2024

Hello,

  • MBA Abroad:

    • Pros:
      • Global exposure, networking, and diverse cultures.
      • Access to top companies and international job markets.
      • Higher earning potential post-graduation.
    • Cons:
      • High tuition fees and living costs.
      • Limited job opportunities for non-citizens in some countries.
      • Requires work experience for most top programs.
  • MBA in India:

    • Pros:
      • Relatively lower fees compared to abroad.
      • Familiar culture and job market.
      • Top Indian schools like IIMs are highly ranked globally.
    • Cons:
      • May not offer global exposure.
      • Competitive admissions, especially without work experience.
  • Chances of Admission (with Bad Academics, No Work Experience):

    • CAT/GMAT Scores:
      • A high score can improve your chances, but without work experience and a strong academic record, it’s challenging to secure admission to top Indian or global schools.
      • Networking, strong essays, and interview performance become crucial factors.

Hope it helps !

2 Comments
Comments (2)
4th Dec, 2024
Thankyou for your valuable guidance. I have a very important question. Right now I am in the 3rd year of my regular btech in electrical engineering. the placement in our college is next to zero but fortunately I have connection to get in some decent companies but at a low level post (junior engineer). If I join a company can I show the work experience for the same year that I was pursuing my btech. Will it be valid , like they won't ask questions that how were you doing a full time job and a regular course at the same time ? Please guide if it will be valid or I should only do internships .
Reply
5th Dec, 2024
Harshit No, it is generally not valid to show full-time work experience during the same period you were pursuing a full-time regular course, as it raises questions about how you managed both simultaneously. Employers may view this as a red flag unless the work was part-time, freelance, or remote and can be clearly justified.

Instead, focus on internships or part-time roles related to your field. These are easier to explain and align well with your academic timeline. If you have connections, leverage them for internships or project-based work, which you can later highlight as relevant experience without misrepresentation.
Reply
kumardurgesh1802 4th Dec, 2024

Hello Harshit,

Choosing between an MBA abroad or in India depends on your career goals and financial situation:

  • MBA Abroad: Offers global exposure, international networking, and high brand value (e.g., Harvard, INSEAD). However, it’s expensive and competitive, especially for applicants with low academic records and no work experience.

  • MBA in India: More affordable (e.g., IIMs, ISB), with strong ties to the Indian job market. It's more accessible with a good CAT score, even with weaker academics, though work experience helps.

For someone with no work experience and low academics, the CAT score is crucial in India, while abroad you may need to highlight other strengths (e.g., extracurriculars) to get in. Focus on improving CAT/GMAT scores to boost your chances.


For more details, you can check out an article by Careers360 whose link is given below:

Link: https://bschool.careers360.com/articles/mba-in-india-vs-abroad


I hope this answer helps you. If you have more queries then feel free to share your questions with us we will be happy to assist you.

Thank you and wishing you all the best for your bright future.

1 Comment
Comments (1)
4th Dec, 2024
Thankyou for your valuable guidance. I have a very important question. Right now I am in the 3rd year of my regular btech in electrical engineering. the placement in our college is next to zero but fortunately I have connection to get in some decent companies but at a low level post (junior engineer). If I join a company can I show the work experience for the same year that I was pursuing my btech. Will it be valid , like they won't ask questions that how were you doing a full time job and a regular course at the same time ? Please guide if it will be valid or I should only do internships .
Reply
Samprikta Mondal 4th Dec, 2024

Whether you do when MBA in India or in abroad it depends on several factors, including your academic background work experience . They both have their advantages and disadvantages. MBA in India is generally more affordable than International programs and their strong Local Network that can help you secure jobs in the Indian companies. You will be more familar and with the Indian business environment. And it also has a strong focus on the Indian market.That disadvantages would be there is less Global exposure. And also the ROI might be lower compared to the international programs. If you do MBA and abroad you will gain exposure to diverse cultures and business practices .you  connect with leaders from  outside world and also industry professionals. You will have a higher ROI also will have access to latest business trends.Disadvantages would be that the tuition fees is very high and also the Visa and the immigration processes can be Complex you have to adapt to a new culture so that can be difficult too. but as you have a lack of work experience then MBA in India might be a more practical choice. if you have strong Academic credentials and can secure good GMAT scores you can consider trying to top International program.You must gain some work experience and also aim for a high GMAT score. Even with bad academic background, you can cover that up with some work experience, if you want t go ahead without these 2 then aim for an excellent score in CAT OR GMAT an prepare for interviews as well. You can definitely succeed. GMAT

CAT

1 Comment
Comments (1)
4th Dec, 2024
Thanks for the valuable guidance. I have a very important question. Right now I'm in Electrical engineering , btech third year regular course . The placement record in our college is next to zero . Fortunately I have the connection to get in a decent company but the post will be very low (junior engineer) ,If I join a company now ,can I show the work experience for the same year that I was pursuing my btech. Will it be valid ,like the won't ask questions that how were you doing a full time job and a full time course at the same time . Should I do it or I should only try for an internship.
Reply

Know More About

Related Questions

UPES Integrated LLB Admission...
Apply
Ranked #28 amongst Institutions in India by NIRF | Ranked #1 in India for Academic Reputation by QS University Rankings | 16.6 LPA Highest CTC
ICFAI-LAW School BA-LLB / BBA...
Apply
Ranked 1 st among Top Law Schools of super Excellence in India - GHRDC | NAAC A+ Accredited | #36 by NIRF
Great Lakes PGPM & PGDM 2025
Apply
Admissions Open | Globally Recognized by AACSB (US) & AMBA (UK) | 17.3 LPA Avg. CTC for PGPM 2024 | Application Deadline: 1st Dec 2024
Chandigarh University Admissi...
Apply
Ranked #1 Among all Private Indian Universities In QS Asia Rankings 2025 | Scholarships worth 210 CR
Amity University, Noida Law A...
Apply
700+ Campus placements at top national and global law firms, corporates, and judiciaries
ISBR Business School PGDM Adm...
Apply
250+ Companies | Highest CTC 16 LPA | Average CTC 8 LPA | Ranked as Platinum Institute by AICTE for 6 years in a row | Awarded Best Business School...
View All Application Forms

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

150M+ Students
30,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books